Repository navigation
Replace clone with download #7
Description
It seems that to clone a repository from GitHub now you always need to set credentials, whatever URL you are using.
So, I'm proposing to replace repositories (that in general are also an overkill) with the master/main branch content, i.e. instead of cloning with Git we will just download the zip content of one branch from GitHub.
E.g. for this repository the corresponding URL is https://github.com/NNPDF/runcards/archive/refs/heads/master.zip
The other option is to use the latest release, e.g. for PineAPPL the URL to the zip of the last release can be found with a request to:
https://api.github.com/repos/n3pdf/pineappl/releases/latest
(the key in the response is actually zipball_url). Once we have the URL, one GET more and we'll have the zip as well (for tarball replace zip with tar in the key.
Which one do you prefer?
master/main: always updated- latest release: more stable
TODO:
- fix version
- replace repositories with tarballs
- Support config files pinecards#127 (comment)
- purge unused (and thus unmaintained) Git related code
- if possible, drop the whole
pygit2dependency, if not used for anything left
- if possible, drop the whole
- download MadGraph from its new source https://github.com/mg5amcnlo/mg5amcnlo (branch
3.4.1, see Download mg5amc using git pinecards#142) - purge Breeze if not any longer used
Activity
felixhekhorn commentedon Jul 22, 2022
latest release definetely
about which repos are we talking about? because all python stuff (eko, yadism) should come without repo (but via PyPI). If we're not using releases (everywhere) we could likewise give up on poetry ;-)
alecandido commentedon Jul 22, 2022
PineAPPL and MadGraph. In particular, for PineAPPL we need to install the C API, and it's not a great idea to ship it as Python package (but maybe I'm just wrong...).
scarlehoff commentedon Jul 22, 2022
It should be possible to clone with no credentials. That said, agree with the following:
alecandido commentedon Jul 22, 2022
I thought so as well (for public repositories of course), but I was not able to do it with
pygit2and GitHub...Ok, let's go for latest then! (unless @cschwan is strongly against it...)
felixhekhorn commentedon Jul 25, 2022
I guess also vrap @scarlehoff ?
and to be more precise: let's not use
latest, but a fixed version! to be specific for PineAPPL this would beimport pineappl; pineappl.__version__as defined bypyprojectalecandido commentedon Jul 25, 2022
Ok, that might be fine as well
P.S.: for the non-python dependencies instead, I will hard-code versions in the package
[-]Replace clone with donwload[/-][+]Replace clone with download[/+]alecandido commentedon Oct 23, 2024
For the record: it is also possible to directly download tarballs even from Launchpad
E.g. https://bazaar.launchpad.net/~maddevelopers/mg5amcnlo/simple_unlops/tarball/973
Of course, it is also supported by GitLab (and yes, also by GitHub, otherwise this issue would have not existed at all).
This should make it completely possible to replace all clones by direct downloads of the required projects' versions (from any of the hosts we usually deal with).