Repository navigation
Index in the road markings is missing #237
Description
In the road marking class the enum RoadMarking_Classification_Color is missing the index 4. This is very troublesome for the test procedures since a random number from 0 - 7 does not cover all the cases and the range is wrong. It would be very nice if someone could take a look at this.
Activity
pmai commentedon May 22, 2018
This seems to be a hold-over from the initial OSI commit, which already did not contain a color with index 4. We should likely fix this at some time; for OSI 3.x we can only fix this by adding a new color with index 4 (maybe a relevant color is still missing?), renumbering would only be possible with 4.x.
Can someone check this with relevant users?
carsten-kuebler commentedon Aug 20, 2018
@LudwigFriedmannBMW As Pierre points out, a re-sort leads to a major version change (4.x). Adding a new color could close the gap (3.1.x). Should we disallow missing elements in enums (e.g. by a test)? This would be different from numbering of the attributes in the messages.
yash-shah-asam commentedon Apr 24, 2025
@thomassedlmayer Could you please take a look at this in the Sensor modeling group?
thomassedlmayer commentedon Apr 30, 2025
Sensor Modeling Meeting (2025-04-30): We could add the color black? We at least found some examples with black road markings: