Skip to content

Feature Request: Add global top-level comments to reviews in plannotator-review #1527

Closed as not planned

Description

@JcMinarro

Summary

When using plannotator-review (either on a Pull Request or a local set of changes not linked to a PR), users can currently leave inline comments on specific lines and comments on full individual files.

It would be very useful to support global top-level comments that apply to the overall review/change, rather than being bound to a specific file or line.

Use Case / Motivation

Often, a code review includes feedback that isn't tied to a specific line of code or single file—such as:

  • High-level architectural feedback or overall design suggestions.
  • General summary notes (e.g., "Overall looks great, but please check the CI pipeline build error").
  • Feedback that impacts multiple files across the entire PR/change set.

Having a dedicated space or UI element to input a global summary comment before finalizing the review would make plannotator-review feel more complete and closely align with standard PR review workflows (e.g., GitHub's PR approval/comment summary box).

Proposed Solution

  • Add an optional "Global Comment" / "Overall Feedback" input field in the review UI/CLI before submitting.
  • Include this top-level comment in the exported/posted review output alongside file and inline comments.

Activity

  1. backnotprop commented on Sep 14, 2026

    @backnotprop
    Owner

    This exists as of v0.27.12. In the review sidebar's Annotations tab, + General comment adds a review-level comment not tied to any file or line. It shows even with zero comments, exports under a ## General section for the agent, and in PR mode posts as the review's top-level body. The decision control's caret also has Send with a note… and Approve with a note… for a one-off summary at submit time.

    Closing as already shipped. If you're on 0.27.12 or later and not seeing the button, or you had a different idea in mind, reopen with the version and surface and we'll look.

  2. JcMinarro commented on Sep 14, 2026

    @JcMinarro
    Author

    Thank you @backnotprop!
    I hadn't noticed this button before, even while using v0.27.14.
    I think it's a bit hidden.
    I was looking for it in:

    • The top bar, similar to "file comments"
    • Above the list of files

    Never mind, thanks a lot for pointing out where it is!

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Labels

    No labels
    No labels

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions