Repository navigation
Open
Description
Environment
- Operating System:
Linux - Node Version:
v26.13.0 - Package Manager:
npm@11.20.0 - Comark Version:
0.9.2(andmainat632e874) - Framework:
None
Comark Version
v0.9.2 (also reproduces on main at 632e874)
Reproduction
Playground links (open the Formatted tab to see renderMarkdown output):
0.start: https://comark.dev/play#code/M9BTqEotyucy1FPIz0vlAgA- Adjacent lists: https://comark.dev/play#code/01VI5NJVSOLi0lZI5gIA
- Nesting under
10.: https://comark.dev/play#code/MzTQUyhJzeNSAAJdhbzU4pLUFC4A - Nested emphasis: https://comark.dev/play#code/04pPy8-P1-ICAA
- Multi-line heading: https://comark.dev/play#code/c8vP50pKLOKytbXlAgA
Minimal script (npm i comark@0.9.2 and node repro.mjs):
import { parseMarkdown } from 'comark'
import { renderMarkdown } from 'comark/render'
const cases = [
'0. zero\n1. one\n',
'- a\n- b\n\n+ c\n',
'10. ten\n - nested\n',
'*_foo_*\n',
'Foo\nbar\n===\n',
]
for (const md of cases) {
const before = await parseMarkdown(md)
const rendered = await renderMarkdown(before)
const after = await parseMarkdown(rendered)
console.log(JSON.stringify({
input: md,
rendered,
before: before.nodes,
after: after.nodes,
}))
}Description
renderMarkdown produces Markdown that re-parses to a different AST in five CommonMark cases:
- Ordered list starting at
0:0. zero\n1. one\nrenders as1. zero\n2. one, losingstart: "0".handlers/ol.tsclampsstart >= 1 ? start : 1whileIMPLICIT_ATTRSdropsstart, though CommonMark 0.31.2 allows0as an ordered list start number. - Adjacent lists of the same kind:
- a\n- b\n\n+ c\nparses as twoulnodes, butrenderMarkdownwrites both with-, producing- a\n- b\n\n- c, which re-parses as one three-itemul. Adjacentolnodes using.and)merge the same way. - Nested lists under item
10or higher:10. ten\n - nested\n(or item 10+ in a1.list) renders as10. ten\n - nestedwith 3 spaces of indent instead of 4, so- nestedfalls out of the item and ends theolon re-parse.handlers/ol.tshardcodeslistIndent: 3instead of usingprefix.lengthfromhandlers/li.ts. - Nested emphasis:
*_foo_*\n(eminsideem) renders as**foo**, which re-parses asstrong.handlers/emphesis.tsalways writes*...*. - Multi-line headings:
Foo\nbar\n===\n(['h1', { id: 'foo-bar' }, 'Foo\nbar']) renders as# Foo\nbar, which re-parses ash1(Foo) followed by ap(bar).
Additional context
None of these five cases is in #525.
Logs
{"input":"0. zero\n1. one\n","rendered":"1. zero\n2. one","before":[["ol",{"start":"0"},["li",{},"zero"],["li",{},"one"]]],"after":[["ol",{},["li",{},"zero"],["li",{},"one"]]]}
{"input":"- a\n- b\n\n+ c\n","rendered":"- a\n- b\n\n- c","before":[["ul",{},["li",{},"a"],["li",{},"b"]],["ul",{},["li",{},"c"]]],"after":[["ul",{},["li",{},"a"],["li",{},"b"],["li",{},"c"]]]}
{"input":"10. ten\n - nested\n","rendered":"10. ten\n - nested","before":[["ol",{"start":"10"},["li",{},["p",{},"ten"],["ul",{},["li",{},"nested"]]]]],"after":[["ol",{"start":"10"},["li",{},"ten"]],["ul",{},["li",{},"nested"]]]}
{"input":"*_foo_*\n","rendered":"**foo**","before":[["p",{},["em",{},["em",{},"foo"]]]],"after":[["p",{},["strong",{},"foo"]]]}
{"input":"Foo\nbar\n===\n","rendered":"# Foo\nbar","before":[["h1",{"id":"foo-bar"},"Foo\nbar"]],"after":[["h1",{"id":"foo"},"Foo"],["p",{},"bar"]]}Credit: https://ucsbplse.github.io/
Metadata
Metadata
Assignees
Labels
No labels
Activity