Skip to content

TOA-358 Phase 1 Complete: Owner Decision Session Needed for D1–D8 Gates #489

Open

Description

@ashleyshaw

Summary

Phase 1 of the Guidelines Refactor specification (TOA-358) is complete. All requirement-quality validation checklists, implementation plan, and decision-gathering template are ready for review.

Blocking item: Phase 2 implementation cannot start until the owner provides decisions on 7 pending gates (D1–D6, D8).

Action Required

  1. Review the decision-gathering template: .github/specs/003-refactor-guidelines/DECISION-GATHERING-TEMPLATE.md
  2. Complete each gate decision section (D1, D2, D3, D4, D5, D6, D8) with:
    • Decision statement (what was decided)
    • Rationale (why this aligns with site goals)
    • Evidence link (where decision is documented)
  3. Record completed decisions in .github/specs/003-refactor-guidelines/checklists/requirements.md (lines 30–43)

Critical Blocking Gate

D4: Documentation Destinations & N-Document Approval Subset is the critical blocker:

  • Specifies which of 33 proposed N-documents are approved for creation
  • Defines G→N consolidation mapping strategy
  • Gates all N-document creation tasks (T028–T032)

Without D4 resolved, Phase 2 cannot proceed.

Reference Materials

  • Specification: .github/specs/003-refactor-guidelines/spec.md
  • Implementation Plan: .github/specs/003-refactor-guidelines/plan.md
  • Task Breakdown: .github/specs/003-refactor-guidelines/tasks.md
  • Decision Template: .github/specs/003-refactor-guidelines/DECISION-GATHERING-TEMPLATE.md
  • Requirement-Quality Checklists:
    • checklists/spec-completeness.md (45 validation items)
    • checklists/implementation-readiness.md (65 validation items)
    • checklists/contract-validation.md (65 validation items)
    • checklists/data-model-validation.md (85 validation items)

Timeline

  • Decision Session: This week (by 2026-10-31 recommended)
  • Phase 2 Start: Once D1–D8 decisions are recorded with evidence
  • Phase 2 Duration: 23–41 hours (6–8 hours per 30 guidelines × 3.8 guideline groups)
  • Phase 3 Verification: 4–6 hours

Related PR

Draft PR #477: docs/spec-003-guidelines-reconcile — contains all Phase 1 artifacts (pending owner decision session to unblock Phase 2)


🤖 Generated by Claude Code

https://claude.ai/code/session_01XebMWGBnw3CXw4PeBAHdRm

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

No one assigned

    Type

    No type

    Fields

    Priority

    None yet

    Projects

    No projects

      Milestone

      No milestone

      Relationships

      None yet

      Development

      No branches or pull requests

      Issue actions