Skip to content

review: readme - Validate coverage and prepare the handoff #546

Open

Description

@ashleyshaw

Code Review Summary

Validate the completed README changes against the accepted audit ledger, implementation boundaries and acceptance criteria. Produce a revision-specific recommendation and handoff.

Documentation review does not establish application, deployment or accessibility compliance.

Linked Stories/Tasks/PRs/Epic

This issue reviews the root and nested README implementation outcomes under the README refresh parent. The audit epic supplies the accepted coverage and scope baseline.

Do not change existing issue ownership, hierarchy or acceptance criteria.

Milestones & Timeline

No deadline or estimate proposed. Review after both implementation outcomes are available.

Areas to Review

  • Inventory completeness, including unchanged and blocked files
  • Root setup, commands, paths, routes and navigation
  • Nested README rendering, links, fragments and examples
  • Current versus historical claims
  • Protected-file boundaries and overlap decisions
  • Actual changes against the approved file scope

Review Checklist

  • Identify the exact reviewed revision
  • Reconcile every README with the accepted ledger
  • Check rendering and local links using approved methods
  • Compare documented commands with committed configuration
  • Distinguish static inspection from executed verification
  • Preserve historical evidence and attribution
  • Record failed, omitted, pending and unassessed checks
  • Identify subsequent unreviewed changes

Acceptance Criteria

  • Every README disposition reconciles with the audit
  • Findings include evidence, impact and recommended action
  • Fixed findings have resolving revision and verification evidence
  • Deferred or accepted-risk findings include rationale
  • Handoff identifies changed files, checks and remaining blockers
  • Reviewer recommendation is separate from human approval
  • Merge readiness and parent completion remain separate decisions

Additional Context

Record review outcomes in this issue. No repository report file, automatic correction or follow-up issue is proposed.

Return required corrections to the existing implementation scope or a separately approved proposal. Do not infer successful builds, live behaviour or compliance from README changes.

Branch instructions

Not applicable: review-only work. No branch creation, repository edits, merge, branch deletion or issue closure is authorised.

Definition of Ready

  • Implementation revision available
  • Accepted audit ledger and scope available
  • Review criteria mapped

Definition of Done

  • Agreed scope reviewed with limitations disclosed
  • Findings have explicit dispositions
  • Outstanding decisions and next-owner actions documented
  • Review recommendation handed over

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Type

No type

Fields

Priority

None yet

Projects

No projects

    Milestone

    No milestone

    Relationships

    None yet

    Development

    No branches or pull requests

    Issue actions