Skip to content
Merged
Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension

Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,8 +1,8 @@
# Coverage Matrix: Spec 001 Requirements → Tasks → Evidence → Verification

**File**: `.github/specs/001-repo-governance-layout-and-agentic-workflows/coverage.md`
**Purpose**: Traceability from each requirement identifier to its implementing tasks, child issues, verification method, and current status
**Prepared**: October 22, 2026
**File**: `.github/specs/001-repo-governance-layout-and-agentic-workflows/coverage.md`
**Purpose**: Traceability from each requirement identifier to its implementing tasks, child issues, verification method, and current status
**Prepared**: October 22, 2026
**Base**: develop @ c9dd145fbb5ee59544393e91abb114806ad95a61

---
Expand Down
35 changes: 22 additions & 13 deletions reports/repo-governance/2026-10-22-spec-001-consistency-review.md
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
Expand Up @@ -145,45 +145,54 @@ Tasks without confirmed evidence or awaiting manual steps:
- **T064** (Protected-file revalidation) — Awaiting guard rerun post-approval
- **T065** (Final handoff) — Deferred until T060–T064 complete

### Historical / Already Delivered (68 total)

- PR #346 merged: governance automation infrastructure delivered
- PR #429 merged: Phase 9 convergence documentation merged to develop
- No blockers to reading historical artifacts; oversight not needed for reconciliation scope

---

## Discrepancies & Clarifications

### "62-Task Main List" vs. 69 Actual Tasks
### "62-Task Main List" vs. 68 Actual Tasks

**Resolution**: The "62-task main list" refers to T001–T062 (Phases 1–8 implementation). Phase 9 adds T055–T065 (convergence and final validation), bringing the total to 69. Phase 9 items are contingent on outstanding approval gates.
**Resolution**: The "62-task main list" refers to T001–T062 (Phases 1–8 implementation). Phase 9 adds T055–T065 (convergence and final validation), bringing the total to 68 (union of T001–T065 plus T017a–T017c). Clarification: is Phase 9 in scope for this reconciliation, or is it a separate handoff?

### "40-Entry Supplementary Plan"

**Resolution**: Not found as a distinct document. The plan.md exists (230 lines) but lists 8 phases, 5 workstreams, and ~59 tasks. The "40-entry supplementary plan" may refer to:
**Resolution**: Not found as a distinct document. The plan.md exists (230 lines) but lists 8 phases, 5 workstreams, and ~59 tasks. Possibility: "40-entry supplementary plan" refers to:
- (a) The 40+ line items in plan.md's "Project Structure" section
- (b) A proposed second planning document not yet created
- (c) An artifact to generate during implementation
- (c) An artifact to generate during this reconciliation

Recommend clarification with @ashley on whether this supplementary plan is needed or already integrated into plan.md.
**Recommendation**: Clarify whether the 40-entry supplementary plan should be:
1. Extracted from existing plan.md and documented separately
2. Created as a new roadmap or timeline artifact
3. Omitted (scope not needed)

### Requirements Baseline (33 → 34)

**Resolution**: The added requirement is **R9 Spec Kit Integration** (R9.1–R9.2), which documents the feature directory routing and regression testing contract. No conflict between 33 and 34; R9 is a necessary addition.
**Resolution**: The added requirement is **R9 Spec Kit Integration** (R9.1–R9.2), which documents the feature directory routing and regression testing contract. This was a missing category in the earlier baseline. No conflict between 33 and 34; it's a necessary addition.

---

## Outstanding Approval Boundaries

### Protected-Files Guard Failure (T055)

**Status**: PR #429 Check Protected Files job failed due to changes to `.github/workflows/`, `scripts/`, `AGENTS.md`, and `CHANGELOG.md`.
**Blocker Status**: PR #429 Check Protected Files job failed due to changes to `.github/workflows/`, `scripts/`, `AGENTS.md`, and `CHANGELOG.md`.

**Approval Evidence**: Reference recorded in lightspeedwp/.github#3975 documents the change request. Successful guard rerun requires:
1. Owner approval of protected-file modifications
1. Owner approval of protected-file modifications (recorded in org-wide issue)
2. Re-run of Check Protected Files workflow after approval handling updated
3. Confirmation of passing result

**Action for Next Round**: Document approval boundary and revalidation path in Phase 9 implementation prompt.
**Action Required**: Issue #409 scope does not include executing T055 guard rerun; only documenting the approval boundary.

### Manual GitHub Settings Steps (T038, T061, T062)

**Status**: Three tasks require GitHub Settings access:
**Blocker Status**: Three tasks require GitHub Settings access:
- **T038/T061**: Enable branch protection on `develop` and `main` branches
- **T062**: Enable Discussions in repository settings and configure categories

Expand All @@ -194,13 +203,13 @@ Recommend clarification with @ashley on whether this supplementary plan is neede
## Conclusion

Specification 001 contains:
- ✅ **34 requirements** properly mapped to 69 tasks across 9 phases and 5 workstreams
- ✅ **46 tasks fully implemented and verified** with no breaking changes
- ✅ **34 requirements** properly mapped to 68 tasks across 9 phases and 5 workstreams
- ✅ **59 tasks fully implemented and verified** with no breaking changes
- ✅ **9 tasks pending completion** (manual GitHub steps, verification tests, guard rerun)
- ✅ **No conflicts between baseline requirements and recorded identifiers** (R9 is a necessary addition)
- ⏳ **Phase 9 convergence documentation merged; gates outstanding** (approval, manual steps, revalidation)

Ready for owner review and next-round implementation prompt addressing Phase 9 items and approval gate resolution.
**Ready for**: Next-round implementation prompt addressing the 9 outstanding tasks (including T035 and T038, outside Phase 9) and clarifying scope boundaries.

---

Expand Down
Loading