You signed in with another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You signed out in another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.You switched accounts on another tab or window. Reload to refresh your session.Dismiss alert
I’m interested in implementing this. I’m considering a weighted attack—akin to how A* pathfinding works—that, while preserving the existing attack behavior, prioritizes locations closer to the mouse click.
I’m interested in implementing this. I’m considering a weighted attack—akin to how A* pathfinding works—that, while preserving the existing attack behavior, prioritizes locations closer to the mouse click.
I may be too late to the discussion, but changing the default behavior of left clicking seems to me to be quite a drastic change and will most likely confuse players a lot. I would suggest keeping left clicking to the default and binding this directed attack to G, and adding it to the attack menu (to make sure mobile players can also do it).
Also, I am all for this change, but it should be noted that this will affect game balance a lot, attacks will be a lot more powerful (because it will be easier to force annexations), so caution should be in place.
Reacted by VariableVince, abec3 and Trajkov Dimitar
I would like to bump the idea of this. I think a simpler way to fix the problem of "extremely" condensed attacks - instead of trying to figure out complicated math and tweak direction weights etc. consider it a bit more similar to boating. Divide borders into fronts. Every separate border is their own front, and fronts have a max size of for example 500 border tiles. Then whatever front is closest to the click location (and connected), it just lets that front push.
The configuration is then in the size of a front, instead of complicated math equations with weights. I think this'd simplify the idea significantly and also make more intuitive sense for many players. (I click near this border - I expect this border to push, not somewhere else across the map)
Activity
APuddle210 commentedon Apr 15, 2025
I know this is still something we want to implement.
dberweger2017 commentedon May 4, 2025
I’m interested in implementing this. I’m considering a weighted attack—akin to how A* pathfinding works—that, while preserving the existing attack behavior, prioritizes locations closer to the mouse click.
leo-210 commentedon May 10, 2025
Any progress ? I could implement it if not
evanpelle commentedon May 17, 2025
It's unassigned if anyone wants to take this.
11 remaining items
TheGiraffe3 commentedon Oct 16, 2025
@nottirb how have things been going?
nottirb commentedon Oct 16, 2025
Was working on a different feature which just went into v26, so swapping back to this now :)
Lavodan commentedon Oct 26, 2025
I may be too late to the discussion, but changing the default behavior of left clicking seems to me to be quite a drastic change and will most likely confuse players a lot. I would suggest keeping left clicking to the default and binding this directed attack to G, and adding it to the attack menu (to make sure mobile players can also do it).
Also, I am all for this change, but it should be noted that this will affect game balance a lot, attacks will be a lot more powerful (because it will be easier to force annexations), so caution should be in place.
TheGiraffe3 commentedon Dec 19, 2025
@Sgt-lewis I don't think this has been completed, as #2262 hasn't been merged yet.
JB940 commentedon Sep 4, 2026
I would like to bump the idea of this. I think a simpler way to fix the problem of "extremely" condensed attacks - instead of trying to figure out complicated math and tweak direction weights etc. consider it a bit more similar to boating. Divide borders into fronts. Every separate border is their own front, and fronts have a max size of for example 500 border tiles. Then whatever front is closest to the click location (and connected), it just lets that front push.
The configuration is then in the size of a front, instead of complicated math equations with weights. I think this'd simplify the idea significantly and also make more intuitive sense for many players. (I click near this border - I expect this border to push, not somewhere else across the map)