Repository navigation
spec(audit): require command evidence in a blocked diagnostic - #682
simonheimlicher wants to merge 4 commits into
Conversation
DEBT [consistency]: spx/21-spec-tree.enabler/68-audit.enabler/audit.md:25Reference: the amended ALWAYS assertion requires a run that reaches none of the final statuses to return the blocked diagnostic naming the failed command, or the absent prerequisite a failed command established, with that command evidence in the diagnostic exitCode and stderr lines -- a started run returns no blocked diagnostic without one of those three shapes. The new NEVER assertion on line 27 bars rendering the run driver own partial, truncated, or unfinished reading as the failed command of a blocked diagnostic. |
f7f4713 to
8c7e49e
Compare
BLOCKING [consistency]: spx/21-spec-tree.enabler/68-audit.enabler/audit.md:25Reference: the amended ALWAYS assertion at line 25: "requires a run that reaches none of those to return the blocked diagnostic naming the failed command, or the absent prerequisite a failed command established, with that commands evidence in the diagnostics exitCode and stderr lines: ... a started run returns no blocked diagnostic without one of those three shapes." |
…nostic State the three command-evidence shapes a started implementation-audit run's blocked diagnostic carries, and bar an unfinished reading from standing as the failed command. Remove the two coordination-note entries this settles. Refs: spx/21-spec-tree.enabler/68-audit.enabler Verification: not-run
The skill the notes describe is unchanged by this changeset, so both entries stay in the node until the skill reconciliation settles them. Refs: spx/21-spec-tree.enabler/68-audit.enabler
The blocked-diagnostic assertion forbids the skill's no-evidence branch for an unfinished unit; the node now records the gap and its settlement condition. Refs: spx/21-spec-tree.enabler/68-audit.enabler
8c7e49e to
7626e60
Compare
DEBT [consistency]: spx/21-spec-tree.enabler/68-audit.enabler/audit.md:25Reference: the same ALWAYS assertion states the blocked diagnostic carries "that commands evidence in the diagnostics |
The third evidence shape of the blocked diagnostic now gives both diagnostic lines a value: exitCode none and the tool's name and error text in stderr. Refs: spx/21-spec-tree.enabler/68-audit.enabler
|
BLOCKING [consistency]: spx/21-spec-tree.enabler/68-audit.enabler/audit.md:25Reference: |



Summary
BLOCKEDonly for a failed command with evidence.Background
An implementation auditor sealed unfinished reading as
BLOCKED, and its dispatcher repaired the result. The blocked-diagnostic assertion now states what a started run's diagnostic carries, so unfinished reading never passes as repairable.Changes
spx/21-spec-tree.enabler/68-audit.enabler/audit.md: the blocked-diagnosticALWAYSassertion names the failed command, or the absent prerequisite a failed command established, with that command's evidence in theexitCodeandstderrlines, in one of three shapes. A started run returns no blocked diagnostic without one of them.spx/21-spec-tree.enabler/68-audit.enabler/audit.md: a newNEVERassertion bars rendering the run driver's own partial, truncated, or unfinished reading as the failed command of a blocked diagnostic.src/plugins/spec-tree/skills/audit-implementation/SKILL.mdstays unchanged. Its reconciliation, the twoISSUES.mdentries in the node, and the assertion auditor's debt finding on that skill settle with outcomeeng/changes#574.Test plan
spx validation markdownpassesjust eval-linkspassesspx spec status --format jsonexits zerospx/21-spec-tree.enabler/68-audit.enabler/audit.mdagainstorigin/mainRefs
Validation
Need help on this PR? Tag
@codesmith-botwith what you need.