Skip to content

False positive CVEs: VLC for Android CVE-2026-26227 and CVE-2026-26228 match desktop VLC #55057

Open

Description

@aliaska-varieva

Fleet version: current main

What happens

Desktop VLC (3.0.x on macOS and Windows) is reported vulnerable to CVE-2026-26227 and CVE-2026-26228. Both affect only VLC for Android (Remote Access Server feature, fixed in VLC for Android 3.7.0).

Cause

NVD has both CVEs in Deferred status, so there is no NVD configuration. The CNA record (VulnCheck) lists the product as "VLC for Android", < 3.7.0, without platform or CPE. The VulnCheck CPE data that Fleet's feed uses turns this into:

cpe:2.3:a:videolan:vlc:*:*:*:*:*:*:*:*   versionEndExcluding: 3.7.0

With target_sw=*, every desktop VLC below 3.7.0 matches, and the desktop line is 3.0.x. The matcher behaves correctly; the input drops the Android platform.

Expected

These CVEs only match VLC on Android (target_sw=android).

Suggested fix

A CPEMatchingRule in server/vulnerabilities/nvd/cpe_matching_rules.go, the same as the existing CVE-2024-3219 rule:

IgnoreIf: func(cpeMeta *wfn.Attributes) bool {
	return cpeMeta.TargetSW != "android"
},

The same pattern (an "X for Android" product mapped to the desktop CPE with target_sw=*) can affect other VulnCheck-sourced CVEs, so a more general check may be worth considering. We've also reported the data issue to VulnCheck.

A PR with the rule will follow.

Activity

  1. moved this from 📨 Inbox to 🦤 ‎In review in 🛡️ #g-supply-chainon Oct 19, 2026
  2. added this to the 4.95.0 milestone on Oct 20, 2026
  3. added a commit that references this issue on Oct 21, 2026
    8daf266
  4. moved this from 🦤 ‎In review to ✔️Awaiting QA in 🛡️ #g-supply-chainon Oct 21, 2026
  5. marcusallen97 commented on Nov 13, 2026

    @marcusallen97
    Contributor

    QA Summary

    Validated PR #55058 (issue #55057, VLC-for-Android CVEs CVE-2026-26227/26228 matching desktop VLC) on the 4.95.0 RC dev server against the local NVD data in /tmp/vulndbs (synced 2026-11-13).

    Check Result Notes
    nvd package tests (TestGetKnownNVDBugRules, TestCPEFromSoftware, TestCPEFromSoftwareIntegration w/ NETWORK_TEST, TestCPEMatchingRule) ✅ all pass on the RC
    Offline RC: VLC 3.0.24 macOS app ✅ videolan:vlc:3.0.24:…:macos, no CVEs
    Offline RC: VLC 3.0.24 pacman ✅ videolan:vlc:3.0.24:…:*, no CVEs
    Offline RC: VLC 3.0.24 Windows program ✅ videolan:vlc_media_player:…:windows, no CVEs (product never referenced by the CVEs)
    Offline RC: VLC 3.0.20 macOS app ✅ CVE-2026-102875 only — rule drops just the two CVEs
    Offline pre-fix: VLC 3.0.24 macOS app / pacman ✅ both report CVE-2026-26227 + CVE-2026-26228 — reproduces the issue
    Android VLC 3.6.5 / 3.7.0 ✅ 3.6.5 → both CVEs; 3.7.0 → none
    Android OS package ✅ no CPE
    Chrome for Android 155 ✅ correct google:chrome CPE (pre-fix 360:chrome, 0 CVEs); 63 Android-targeted vs macOS control, none from OS entries
    Firefox for Android 145 vs pre-fix ✅ 7 iPhone-only CVEs dropped
    Firefox for Android CVE-2017-7759 at 145.0 / 60.0 / 53.0 ❌ matched regardless of version via matchTargetSW and NVD's unversioned o:google:android:- entry; 5 old Firefox CVEs exposed this way; minor → #58685 (~unreleased bug)
    Sibling rule CVE-2024-3219 (Python 3.11.4) ✅ macOS absent, Windows present
    Live install via FMA (hosts 8, 10) + two scans ✅ videolan:vlc_media_player CPEs, no VLC CVEs stored; API/UI empty for both CVEs (pipeline proven; vlc product offline only)
    Live cron health ✅ hourly + manual runs complete, no errors
  6. moved this from ✔️ Awaiting QA to ✅ Ready for release in 🛡️ #g-supply-chainon Nov 13, 2026
Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Metadata

Metadata

Assignees

Labels

#g-supply-chainSupply Chain product group~communityA issue or pull request submitted by the community.

Type

No type

Projects

Milestone

Relationships

None yet

Development

No branches or pull requests

Issue actions