Repository navigation
docs: the current-state kernel rows are 7.4.0-rc1-1bit, not 7.3 - #1139
Conversation
The box, the stick and the release image all run Linux v7.4-rc1 (7.4.0-rc1-1bit) since 2026-11-04, where the IOMMU PerfOpt series is upstream instead of carried as two backports. docs/kernel.md gained only the Runs today bullet (#1121); the rest of the current-state statements still said 7.3, so a reader would take the old pin as today's. - kernel.md: a 7.4 section — PerfOpt upstream, the BTF config and the BPF-object boot noise it removes, gcc 15.2 (not clang), the 7.4-only throughput arm and why it is not a delta, and the two watched issues (NVMe IO_PAGE_FAULT under block I/O, the MES REMOVE_QUEUE reset that is also recorded on 7.3). - releases.md, os-v3.md, architecture.md, PORTING.md: the image/layout/pinned-source rows move to 7.4-rc1; os-v3.md's dated 11-01 measurement table stays as the record with one line saying what runs today. - os/v3/puppy: the huge-kernel and config-fragment comments describe the current build, so they name 7.4.0-rc1-1bit (the =m values they rely on were re-measured in /boot/config-7.4.0-rc1-1bit). Historical records are untouched: the dated PerfOpt A/B table, the 11-01/11-02 Puppy eval log, KNOWN-ISSUES' 2026-10-22 update and the blog posts.
bong-water-water-bong
left a comment
There was a problem hiding this comment.
VERDICT: READY — every claim that is checkable off this box checks out, and the script edits are comments
The point of the PR is that the current-state rows must match what runs, so I checked them against the running kernel rather than against the other docs:
uname -r 7.4.0-rc1-1bit
/boot/config-7.4.0-rc1-1bit CONFIG_DEBUG_INFO_BTF=y (claim: "with CONFIG_DEBUG_INFO_BTF=y")
CONFIG_CC_IS_GCC=y CONFIG_GCC_VERSION=150200 CONFIG_CC_IS_CLANG absent (claim: gcc 15.2.0, not clang)
/sys/kernel/btf/vmlinux 5,207,562 B = 4.97 MiB (claim: "~5 MiB of BTF")
pahole --version v1.31 (claim: "pahole 1.31")
journalctl -k -b amdgpu 0000:c5:00.0: AMD-Vi: PerfOpt armed on IOMMU0 (claim: still armed, upstream)
journalctl -k -b systemd[1]: bpf-restrict-fs: LSM BPF program attached (claim: the "Failed to load BPF
object" noise is gone)
journalctl -k -b nvme 0000:c4:00.0: AMD-Vi: Event logged [IO_PAGE_FAULT] (the watched issue, three times in
this boot alone — it is not theoretical)
The two files under os/v3/puppy/ are comment-only. Filtering the diff to added/removed lines that are not # comments leaves nothing, so the huge-kernel script and the config fragment only gained the current version name — no build step changed. That is the thing to check in a "docs" PR that touches a build script, and it is clean.
The one claim I cannot re-derive is the throughput arm (pp512 239.6, pp2048 234.7, tg128 10.9 at the 90/90/105 W fan curve). It is the lane's measurement, it is labelled as 7.4-arm-only with an explicit statement that no 7.3-vs-7.4 delta is claimed because the 7.3 arm needs its own grub-reboot window — which is the honest way to report a number you cannot compare. I took no GPU ticket for it.
The page's own discipline is worth noting: os-v3.md's dated 2026-11-01 table stays as the record with one line saying what runs today, and the history (PerfOpt A/B table, eval log, KNOWN-ISSUES update, blog posts) is untouched. That is the right split, and it is the reason a reader can still date the older numbers.
PR Reviewer Guide 🔍Here are some key observations to aid the review process:
|
…trings One conflict, docs/PORTING.md's kernel row, which is #1139's: kept its version facts ("upstream tags built into Debian packages - v7.4-rc1 today, v7.3-rc4 before it") and restored this PR's tail naming which os/ target takes which kernel (the Puppy appliance's woof-CE package vs the os/mini CI image's KVER=/VMLINUZ=), since neither side carried both. The three other files main touched among this PR's eleven (docs/kernel.md, docs/os-v3.md, docs/releases.md) auto-merged with both sides intact. pi-os3's ac2f80b (os-v3-live-puppy-eval) is untouched by the merge and still on the tip.
The box, the stick and the release image all run Linux
v7.4-rc1(7.4.0-rc1-1bit) since 2026-11-04, where the IOMMU PerfOpt series is upstream instead of carried as two backports.docs/kernel.mdhad only theRuns todaybullet moved (#1121); every other current-state statement still said 7.3, so a reader took the old pin as today's.Root cause: the 7.4 move was recorded in one place (kernel.md's intro) instead of swept, so the same fact lives in seven files and one of them was updated.
What moves (current-state only):
docs/kernel.mdCONFIG_DEBUG_INFO_BTF=yand thebpf-restrict-fsboot noise it removes, gcc 15.2 (not clang), the 7.4-only throughput arm, the two watched issuesdocs/releases.md7.3.0-rc4-1bit-perfopt7.4.0-rc1-1bitdocs/os-v3.mdCONFIG_EFIVAR_FS=mmeasurement path, theWhat is measured nowpreamblevmlinuz-7.3.0-rc4-1bit-perfopt+vmlinuz-7.4.0-rc1-1bit, plus one line saying what runs todaydocs/architecture.mdv7.3-rc4plus the PerfOpt backportsv7.4-rc1, plain upstreamdocs/PORTING.mdv7.3-rc4built into debsv7.4-rc1todayos/v3/puppy/mk-huge-kernel.sh,kernel-puppy.fragment7.3.0-rc4-1bit-perfopt+7.4.0-rc1-1bitMeasured, not assumed: the two
=mfacts the Puppy fragment depends on were re-read from the booted kernel's/boot/config-7.4.0-rc1-1bit—CONFIG_EFIVAR_FS=m, andSCSI/SCSI_MOD/SCSI_COMMON/CDROM/ATA/SATA_AHCIall still=m, so the fragment's rationale is unchanged on 7.4.Deliberately untouched (historical records): the dated PerfOpt A/B table in
kernel.md, the 2026-11-01/02 Puppy eval log,KNOWN-ISSUES.md's 2026-10-22 update,docs/hrx.md's dated A/B and the blog posts.Honest limit of the throughput line: the 7.3 arm of the current recipe cannot be taken from inside a 7.4 boot, so the page publishes the 7.4 arm with its power profile, says it is not comparable to the older table, and claims no delta.
No NPU driver or kernel-perf internals are described; the out-of-tree driver is named the way the page already named it.